[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: Questions about WWPB



 
> 1.  Is there really evidence that Megatherium and its relatives scavenged flesh occasionally?  
 
None that I have heard of (and I would not consider the jaws or teeth of sloths to be particularly well suited for dealing with meat).  Also, neither of the living sloths (which bracket at least some of the "ground sloths" phylogenetically, although I'm not certain of the position of megatheriids) are meat scavengers, as far as I know.
Some armadillos do scavenge at times. Maybe they jumbled the xenarthrans...
[...] Farina's model of the predatory Megatherium.
?
> 2.  If Basilosaurus used its legs as claspers why do modern whales not require them? 
 
Because modern whales are much smoother operators...  Okay, modern whales demonstate that claspers are not necessary, but it is true that Basilosaurus still had small hindlimbs with apparently functional joints.  I don't know of any reason why they might not be used for this purpose, and various other marine vertebrates have various pelvic claspers.  However, there is no direct evidence that they were used in this fashion.
The procedure takes today's killer whales about 2 hours according to, er, the TV. Some sort of clasper is certainly an advantage in that situation (though probably a disadvantage in swimming and useless most of the year, which apparently adds up to a selective disadvantage).