[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: Details on Tugulusaurus



David Marjanovic wrote-
 
the Iren Debasu therizinosaur
??? Never read of that one...
 
As Jaime already said, it's primarily known from forelimb material (AMNH 6368, humerus, manual phalanx, manual ungual) originally assigned to Alectrosaurus.  New material has been found (Currie and Eberth 1993) and may be synonymous with Erlikosaurus or Segnosaurus.
Usually, the word "arctometatarsalian" is used to describe a third metatarsal that is considerably constricted proximally and a bit expanded distally. It is not necessary that it doesn't reach the ankle. Since it does constrict in Harpymimus and "Ginereemimus" (is this the to-be-correct spelling? Someone stated that it is misspelled in the original and will be corrected, someone else wrote it like here), AFAIK, the arctometatarsus can still be a synapomorphy of Arctometatarsalia.
 
Note that the definition from Tom Holtz in his 1994 paper states that the third metatarsal must be "completely excluded from anterior view".  This is probably not the case in "Ginnareemimus" and Harpymimus.  As for the Arctometatarsalia, it only contains ornithomimosaurs in my phylogenies.  Tyrannosaurs may turn out to be more closely related to ornithomimosaurs than birds, but the relationship between these three groups has yet to be worked out in my cladograms.  Caenagnathids are oviraptorosaurs and troodontids, mononykines and Avimimus are avialans in my analysis (although Avimimus may change position with the new data I have available).  So the arctometatarsus is not a synapomorphy of Arctometatarsalia in my phylogeny.
Does this mean that basal dromaeosaurids still have fourth trochanters?
 
Achillobator, Adasaurus, Velociraptor and some Deinonychus individuals have fourth trochantors.  Some Deinonychus specimens, Unenlagia and Bambiraptor lack them.
What are the apomorphies of alvarezsaurid caudal vertebrae? The pneumatic openings (shared with oviraptorosaurs and many pygostylians)? (This is not intended as a rhethorical question, I just don't know...)
 
Alvarezsaurid caudal centra lack pleurocoels.  The most obvious apomorphy (and reason Tugulusaurus caudal vertebrae are not alvarezsaurid) is the presence of strongly procoelous centra.
 
Mickey Mortimer