[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]
Bird analysis update 3
Deleted *Hulsanpes* and *Ambiortus*. The strict consensus (of 1102 trees,
length 209) is grateful:
+--allzero outgroup
`--+--+--*Caudipteryx*
| `--+--Scansoriopterygidae
| `--+--*Archaeopteryx*
| |--*Microraptor*
| |--basal Troodontidae
| `--+--*Rahonavis*
| |--*Shenzhouraptor*
| `--*Jixiangornis*
`--+--*Sapeornis*
`--+--*Yandangornis*
|--*Omnivoropteryx*
|--*Confuciusornis*
|--*Jibeinia*
`--+--Euornithes (see below)
`--+--*Iberomesornis*
`--Euenantiornithes (grass)
Euornithes
|--*Vorona*
|--*Patagopteryx*
|--*Yanornis*
|--*Yixianornis*
`--+--*Apsaravis*
`--+--*Songlingornis*
|--*Gansus*
`--+--Hesperornithes
`--+--*Ichthyornis*
`--*Anas*
The resolved position of *Iberomesornis*, however, is likely an artifact of
the restricted number of rearrangements -- in other words probably not all
MPTs were found. Originally I forgot to remove *Ambiortus*, and in the
strict consensus of that run Enantiornithes was not resolved at all, even
though *Ambiortus* stayed in Euornithes.
But even if Euenantiornithes is really present in the strict
consensus, the situation still remains that, without reweighting, I haven't
been able to tell the world anything new about enantiornith phylogeny. :-(
The majority-rule consensus resolves the polytomies as follows:
--100--*Microraptor*
|--basal Troodontidae
`--66--*Archaeopteryx*
`--100--*Shenzhouraptor*
`--56--*Rahonavis*
`--*Jixiangornis*
--100--*Sapeornis*
`--100--*Omnivoropteryx*
`--100--*Yandangornis*
`--92--*Confuciusornis*
`--100 *Jibeinia* + Ornithothoraces
Euenantiornithes
|--*Protopteryx*
`--60--*Longipteryx*
`--60--*Noguerornis*
`--72--*Eocathayornis*
|--*Eoenantiornis*
|--84--*Gobipteryx*
| `--97--*Longirostravis*
| `--*Liaoningornis*
`--84--*Sinornis*
`--91--unnamed Lebanon
`--91--*Halimornis*
`--91--*Concornis*
`--91--*Enantiornis*
`--57--94--*Neuquenornis*
| `--*Cuspirostrisornis*
`--54--*Eoalulavis*
`--86--*Soroavisaurus*
`--95--*Avisaurus*
`--*Vescornis*
Euornithes
|--*Vorona*
`--54--*Patagopteryx*
`--100 *Yanornis* + rest
--100--*Songlingornis*
`--87--*Gansus*
`--rest
The Adams consensus has *Confuciusornis* and *Yandangornis* as sistergroups.
In individual trees *Eocathayornis* and *Noguerornis* jump around like
crazy. For example, tree number 1000 has
+--*Gobipteryx*
`--+--*Eocathayornis*
`--+--*Longirostravis*
`--*Liaoningornis*
and
+--+--*Eoalulavis*
| `--+--*Soroavisaurus*
| `--+--*Avisaurus*
| `--*Vescornis*
`--+--*Noguerornis*
`--+--*Cuspirostrisornis*
`--*Neuquenornis*
, not surprising considering how fragmentary *N.* is, and quite surprising
considering how complete and seemingly obviously basal *E.* is. ~:-|
Now for 10 rounds of reweighting...