[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index][Subject Index][Author Index]

Re: E and P of pterosaurs - more comments



> DP: Would a few examples be enough to illustrate the chimaera problem?

One can code polymorphisms. :-) This lets PAUP* sort out which of the 2 or
more states is plesiomorphic within the group, as if its species were coded
separately, but still keeps the matrix small.

> If you have more than one tree in the end, as in Unwin 2003, there's
something wrong, you didn't dig deep enough, because in nature there is only
one tree.

Eh, but there's no possibility to tell _what_'s wrong. Because that could be
the sampling of the fossil record. It doesn't have to be the coding.
(Extreme example -- put *Alexornis* in any matrix of basal birds, and it'll
come out in a polytomy, because it consists mostly of missing data.)